JOVANA
Library Glossary Getting Started Three Levels Fields How it works Mission
Join the mission
Back to the library
Chemistry 1893

Contribution to the Constitution of Inorganic Compounds

Alfred Werner

A metal ion gathers a fixed number of groups into a fixed shape in space.

Choose your version
In depth · the introduction

Cobalt chloride and ammonia — two ordinary substances — combine into a stable solid that the rules of the day said should not hold together. A young chemist explained it by giving the metal atom a second kind of valence and a definite shape in space.

The idea, unpacked

Werner said a metal atom has not one bonding capacity but two. The first is the familiar one — cobalt is “three”, so it pairs with three chlorides. The second is a separate, fixed number of slots — six, for cobalt — into which the atom gathers neighbouring groups and holds them directly, arranged at the corners of an octahedron.

Those six neighbours can be neutral molecules, like ammonia, or charged ones, like chloride. Whether a given chloride sits in one of the six inner slots or floats free outside changes how the compound behaves — how many ions it sheds in water, what colour it is, and even whether two different versions of the same formula can exist.

A theory dreamt at two in the morning

In 1892 Werner was a 26-year-old lecturer in Zürich, trained in organic rather than inorganic chemistry. The story he told is that the solution came to him in the night: he woke around two o'clock, wrote without stopping, and by late afternoon had the paper. Published in 1893, it was an audacious challenge to the reigning authority, the Danish chemist Sophus Jørgensen, whose “chain theory” pictured the extra ammonias linked in chains like carbon's.

For twenty years the two camps made and remade cobalt and platinum compounds, each new substance a test. Werner kept finding exactly the number of forms his octahedron predicted — and no more. The Nobel Prize came in 1913, the first ever given to an inorganic chemist.

Why it mattered

A whole class of compounds had defied the rules; Werner gave them a single, geometric logic. He showed that the architecture of a molecule — what sits where in space — is as real and as decisive for a metal complex as it had already proved for carbon, and that the count of isomers is a fingerprint you can predict in advance. From that grew the chemistry of the coloured, catalytic, metal-centred compounds that run much of industry and all of living cells.

Six seats at the table

Picture the cobalt atom as a host at a table with exactly six seats — arranged not as a flat ring but as the points of an octahedron: four around the middle, one above, one below. Ammonia and chloride are the guests. If two chloride guests take neighbouring seats, the compound is one colour (violet); if they take opposite seats, it is another (green) — same guests, same table, different seating, different substance. And any chloride that finds no seat drifts off into the solution as a free ion.

A central cobalt atom with six bonds pointing to the vertices of an octahedron — four around the middle, one up, one down — each holding an ammonia (blue) or a chloride (green). A slider sets how many chlorides sit inside this coordination sphere (0 to 3); the rest float outside as free chloride ions, and a readout gives the formula and how many particles the salt releases in water. A button reseats two or three bound chlorides between their cis/trans or fac/mer arrangements.

Before and after

Before Werner, valence meant a single whole number per atom, and the “molecular compounds” that broke that rule were patched up with ad hoc chains. After him, the coordinate bond (Lewis and Sidgwick) explained what the secondary valence physically is, and ligand-field theory explained the colours and the magnetism. The line runs straight from his octahedron to cisplatin in the clinic, to the metal–organic frameworks of today, and to the iron, magnesium and zinc centres on which the Library's documents on the oxygen-carrying of blood, on photosynthesis, and on enzymes all quietly depend.

The original document
Original source text
Alfred Werner (1866–1919) · “Beitrag zur Konstitution anorganischer Verbindungen” · Zeitschrift für anorganische Chemie 3 (1893), pp. 267–330
The puzzle of the “molecular compounds”
(Structural map, paraphrased from the German.) Werner begins from an embarrassment of classical valence: stable solids such as CoCl₃·6NH₃, in which a cobalt whose valence is three nonetheless binds six further ammonia molecules. Such “compounds of higher order” had been rationalised by Blomstrand and Jørgensen as chains of ammonia, built like the carbon chains of organic chemistry — a construction Werner sets out to replace.
Primary and secondary valence
(Paraphrase.) His central proposal: a metal possesses two kinds of valence. The primary valence (Hauptvalenz) is the ordinary oxidation number, satisfied by acid anions. The secondary valence (Nebenvalenz) is a separate, fixed capacity — the coordination number — by which the central atom binds a definite number of groups, neutral molecules or anions alike, directly to itself. For trivalent cobalt the coordination number is six.
A definite arrangement in space
(Paraphrase.) The secondary valences are directed: the bound groups occupy fixed positions about the central atom. Werner places the six groups of a coordination number of six at the vertices of a regular octahedron, and treats this geometry as the source both of the compounds' stability and of their isomerism.
The evidence: ionisation and isomer count
(Paraphrase.) The model is tested two ways. Moving a chloride from outside the coordination sphere (ionic, free) to inside it (bound) lowers the number of ions the salt yields in water — a ladder Werner, with Miolati, reads through molar conductivities and through the chloride that silver nitrate can precipitate. And the octahedron predicts the exact number of isomers each formula should show — two, and only two, for MA₄B₂ — a count borne out by the violet and green forms of the tetra-ammine dichloro cobalt salts.
[ … ]
Zürich · 1893