JOVANA
Library Glossary Getting Started Three Levels Fields How it works Mission
Join the mission
Back to the library
Microbiology 1861

Memoir on the Organized Corpuscles in the Atmosphere — Examination of the Doctrine of Spontaneous Generation

Louis Pasteur

He boiled broth in a flask with a curved neck — and proved that the life appearing in it drifts in on dust, and is never born from nothing.

Choose your version
In depth · the introduction

For two thousand years people believed life could simply appear out of broth and rot. One curved glass neck proved them wrong.

The big idea

Leave meat broth out and within days it swarms with microscopic life. For centuries the obvious explanation was that the broth itself had bred the creatures — life arising from non-life, 'spontaneous generation.' Louis Pasteur thought the truth was simpler and stranger: the air is full of invisible living germs, drifting on dust, and they had merely landed and multiplied.

To prove it he needed to let air touch the broth while keeping the dust away — because critics insisted that sealing a flask 'spoiled' the air and so any sterile result was cheating. His answer was a flask with a long neck bent down into an S-shape: a swan neck.

How it came about

Pasteur was a chemist, not a biologist, who had come to microbes sideways — through fermentation, showing that yeasts and bacteria, not mere chemistry, turn grape juice to wine and milk to sour. That convinced him the air carried living things, and it drew him into the fiercest biological controversy of the day. His chief opponent, the naturalist Félix-Archimède Pouchet, was a serious scientist who had his own experiments seeming to show life appearing from nothing.

Pasteur's swan-neck flasks were the decisive stroke: boiled, left open, yet forever clear — until he tipped one so the broth ran up into the bend where the dust had collected, and it clouded over within days. He carried flasks up into the Alps to show that cleaner, higher air seeded far fewer of them. In 1862 the French Academy of Sciences awarded him its prize for the work, and the matter was, for ordinary purposes, closed.

Why it mattered

If germs ride the air and breed from their own kind, then they can be kept out — and that single idea reorganised medicine and food. Surgeons learned to keep germs from wounds (Lister's antisepsis); hospitals learned to sterilise; we learned to can food and to 'pasteurise' milk and wine, gently heating them to kill the microbes, a word that is Pasteur's name. Most of all, disease itself could now be understood as infection by specific living organisms — the foundation on which all of modern microbiology and much of medicine was built.

A way to picture it

Think of the U-shaped bend in the pipe under your kitchen sink. It stays full of a little water, and that trap is what stops the smells and grime of the drain from coming back up into the room — while air can still pass. Pasteur's swan neck is the same trick in reverse: the bend is a trap that catches the dust and germs settling out of the incoming air, so they never reach the broth. Tip the liquid into the trap and you flush the captured germs straight back into your clean broth.

A swan-neck flask of boiled broth with buttons for upright, tip the flask, and break the neck, plus a day slider. Upright, the broth stays clear however many days pass, because dust settles in the curve of the neck; tipping it into the bend or breaking the neck lets germs reach the liquid and it clouds within days.

Where it sits

Pasteur stood at the end of a long argument: Francesco Redi had stopped maggots forming in covered meat in 1668, and Lazzaro Spallanzani had boiled and sealed flasks in 1765, but neither could silence the objection about the air. Pasteur silenced it. His result feeds straight into the others in this Library — John Snow had just argued that cholera travels in water (1855), Joseph Lister would carry germ theory into surgery (1867), and Alexander Fleming's penicillin (1929) would later turn the tables on the same microbes Pasteur first caught drifting in the air.

The original document
Original source text
Louis Pasteur · Mémoire sur les corpuscules organisés qui existent dans l'atmosphère · Annales des sciences naturelles, 4e série, t. 16 · Paris, 1861
Pasteur's thesis: the living things that appear in a boiled, decaying infusion are not generated by the broth itself. They grow from germs — minute organisms suspended in ordinary air, riding on its dust. Keep the dust out, and however freely the air comes and goes, nothing will ever live in the liquid.
The doctrine on trial
For two millennia it was taken for granted that life arises spontaneously from non-living matter — maggots from meat, mice from grain, swarms of microscopic 'animalcules' from any broth left to stand. Redi (1668) had banished the maggots, and Spallanzani (1765) had shown that a sealed, boiled flask stays lifeless; but his critics had a ready answer. Sealing and prolonged boiling, they said, spoils the air or destroys some 'vital force' it carries, so the absence of life proves nothing. To settle it, an experiment was needed that admitted fresh air in full — and excluded only the dust.
The swan-neck flask
Pasteur drew the neck of a flask out in a flame into a long, downward S — a 'swan neck' (col de cygne). He boiled the broth to sterilise it and left the flask open to the air. Air passed freely in and out; but the dust it carried, and the germs upon it, settled in the low bend of the neck and never reached the liquid. The broth stayed clear for months, for years. Then, tilting the flask so the broth ran up into the bend and back, he washed the trapped dust into the liquid — and within days it teemed with life. The air had never been the issue. The dust was.
There is no known circumstance in which it can be affirmed that microscopic beings came into the world without germs, without parents similar to themselves.
[ … ]
Before the Academy
Pasteur reinforced the case from every side. Drawing air through a plug of gun-cotton, he dissolved the plug and found under the microscope a litter of 'organized corpuscles' indistinguishable from the germs that grew in his flasks. Exposing sterile flasks at different places, he found that ordinary cellar and street air seeded almost all of them, while air from a high Alpine glacier seeded very few — the germs were unevenly scattered through the atmosphere, not everywhere and inevitable. For this body of work the Académie des sciences awarded him its prize on spontaneous generation in 1862.
From the 1864 Sorbonne address
Louis Pasteur · « Des générations spontanées », a public lecture · Sorbonne, Paris · 7 April 1864
Never will the doctrine of spontaneous generation recover from the mortal blow that this simple experiment deals it.
Paris · École Normale Supérieure · 1861