JOVANA
Library Glossary Getting Started Three Levels Fields How it works Mission
Join the mission
Back to the library
Physics 1927

A Homogeneous Universe of Constant Mass and Increasing Radius

Georges Lemaître

Space itself stretches; galaxies recede in proportion to distance.

Choose your version
In depth · the introduction

The galaxies aren't flying through space away from us — space itself is stretching, carrying them along, and this is the paper that first said so.

The idea, unpacked

By the 1920s astronomers had a puzzle: nearly every distant galaxy's light was shifted toward the red, the colour you see when a source is moving away. It looked as if the whole sky were fleeing from us. Why should we be at the centre of a great exodus?

Lemaître's answer was to stop thinking of the galaxies as moving and start thinking of space itself as growing. Picture the space between galaxies quietly swelling, like dough rising. Nobody is at the centre; every observer sees everyone else drifting away. And the farther a galaxy is, the more swelling space lies between it and us, so the faster it appears to recede — velocity growing in step with distance.

Where it came from

Georges Lemaître was a Belgian priest and a trained physicist who had studied with Arthur Eddington in Cambridge and visited Hubble's and Slipher's circles in America. In 1927 he combined Einstein's general relativity with the new galaxy measurements and published the result in a small Belgian journal — in French, where almost no one in the wider community saw it.

He even pulled a first number out of the data: galaxies receding at about 625 kilometres per second for every megaparsec of distance. Two years later Edwin Hubble published the same velocity–distance relationship from his own observations, and it was Hubble's name that stuck to the law. Lemaître, characteristically, never pressed his claim.

Why it mattered

If space is expanding now, then run the film backwards and everything was once crammed together. That single thought — which Lemaître pursued into his 1931 idea of a 'primeval atom' — is the seed of the Big Bang, the modern account of how the universe began. The expanding universe also turned cosmology from philosophy into measurement: the rate of expansion became a number you could go out and pin down, and refining it is still front-line science a century later.

A loaf of raisin bread

Imagine raisins dotted through a loaf of dough as it bakes and rises. Each raisin is a galaxy; the dough is space. As the loaf swells, every raisin moves away from every other one — and a raisin twice as far has twice as much dough expanding between you and it, so it pulls away twice as fast. No raisin is the centre; the whole loaf is simply getting bigger. That is exactly Lemaître's picture, and you can drive it yourself below.

An interactive expanding-universe diagram. The upper scene shows galaxies on a slowly stretching grid, with an observer marked 'us' at the left; the lower panel plots recession velocity against distance as a straight line through the origin whose slope is the Hubble parameter H. A slider sets H from 40 to 800 km/s/Mpc, with markers at Lemaître's 1927 value of 625 and today's measured ~70; the readout reports the velocity and redshift of the farthest galaxy.

Where it sits

This note stands on Einstein's general relativity of 1915 and on Friedmann's 1922 mathematics, and it stares directly at Hubble's 1929 measurements — which is why the law is now officially the Hubble–Lemaître law. Looking forward, it opens onto the Big Bang and the 1965 discovery of the cosmic microwave background, the faint afterglow of that hot, dense beginning. The single number it first estimated, the Hubble constant, is still the most argued-over figure in cosmology today.

The original document
Original source text
Abbé G. Lemaître · Annales de la Société Scientifique de Bruxelles, A47, pp. 49–59 (1927) · trans. J.-P. Luminet, Gen. Rel. Grav. 45 (2013) 1635
1. Generalities
Lemaître sets the stage with the two known relativistic universes. De Sitter's ignores matter; Einstein's is static and packed with as much matter as it can hold. Each captures one half of the truth and misses the other.
Each theory has its own advantage. One is in agreement with the observed radial velocities of nebulæ, the other with the existence of matter… It seems desirable to find an intermediate solution which could combine the advantages of both.
2. Einstein universe of variable radius
He treats the universe as a rarefied gas whose molecules are the galaxies, uniformly distributed and pressureless (p = 0), then lets Einstein's radius of space R vary with time. From the field equations he derives how the density and the radius evolve together.
[ … ]
4. Doppler effect due to the variation of the radius of the universe
[v/c] measures the apparent Doppler effect due to the variation of the radius of the universe. It equals the ratio of the radii of the universe at the instants of observation and emission, diminished by unity.
For nearby sources this reduces to v/c = (Ṙ/R)·r — recession velocity proportional to distance. Using 42 nebulae from Hubble's and Strömberg's lists, Lemaître divides their mean velocity by their mean distance:
…one finds a mean distance of 0.95 megaparsecs and a radial velocity of 600 Km/sec, i.e. 625 Km/sec at 10⁶ parsecs.
This number — 625 km/s per megaparsec, written Ṙ/R = 0.68 × 10⁻²⁷ cm⁻¹ — is the first estimate of what would later be called the Hubble constant. (It is too large: the distance scale of the day was miscalibrated.)
6. Conclusion
The recession velocities of extragalactic nebulæ are a cosmical effect of the expansion of the universe.
Lemaître also notes that the universe expands without limit from a finite asymptotic radius, and wonders whether radiation pressure itself set the expansion going — a thread he would pull, two years later, into the idea of a 'primeval atom.'
Abbé G. Lemaître · Louvain · 1927